The Silent Crisis in the Civil Justice System of Bangladesh: Exclusions, Delays, and the Need for Reform

Mobashir Akbar Khan



Introduction

A housewife from a remote village in Bangladesh's northwest filed a land dispute case in order to receive prompt relief. She had no idea at the time that it would be over ten years before there was anything approaching a solution. She had been in a state of perpetual limbo and poverty due to a protracted legal battle that had also damaged her relationships with her family. In Bangladesh, civil justice cases are now routinely handled slowly; Nirmala was hardly an exception. The foundation of Bangladesh's legal system continues to be civil justice. At the core of the civil justice system is the idea of evidence-based enforcement of rights, as opposed to the detention and imprisonment that characterize the criminal court. Its goals are to uphold the rule of law, safeguard individual liberties, and offer a forum for fair trials in order to settle disputes. It is rooted in both contemporary reform and the colonial past's historical legal relics. However, that goal has been undermined by persistent obstacles and structural issues, and there are now significant doubts about how access will change in the future.


The first is digitalization

Even though Bangladesh has embraced the rhetoric of "Digital Bangladesh," the majority of its courts continue to function on paper. Case logs that are handwritten, bureaucratic obstacles, and missing files are examples of inefficiencies. In certain ways, the recently launched E-Judiciary Project has been beneficial; through video hearings, e-filing, and digital case tracking, some cases have been resolved in record time. "With computer-based technology, decisions that once took over a century to make in a courtroom can now be made in minutes," attorney Aazad Chandran says. Over the course of eighteen working days, 1,849 petitions were received. Its application is still far from equal, though. Despite all the evidence that it can also help reduce backlogs in cases and improve transparency, the process has been sluggish in Bangladeshi courts.


Disenfranchised Groups and Gender

Access Inequalities in access to civil justice cases exist, and the backlogs are especially detrimental to women, marginalized communities, and the impoverished in rural areas. Women frequently find themselves in precarious situations during protracted divorce, maintenance, and child custody proceedings. A lawyer is frequently out of reach for vintners, and underrepresented groups are reluctant to file a lawsuit for fear of retaliation or rejection in a relationship-based industry. Community legal services and mediation that is sensitive to gender. Despite being started by UNDP and BRAC, community legal services and gender-sensitive mediation have not yet gained widespread adoption. The first is that, aside from those well-funded legal aid programs, the impoverished still do not have adequate access to the system.


Victim assistance and prison reform

Lost Phases of Prison Reform and Victim Assistance The other side of judicial delay, which is represented in Bangladesh's prison system, is quite different. The vast majority of the inmates in the overcrowded jails have been waiting for their trials for years on end. Organizations that provide aid to victims have also been impacted. Access to housing, witness protection, and psychological care that could aid in their recovery is rarely available to victims of crimes such as sexual assault or domestic abuse. Additionally, research shows that this kind of service has numerous issues and that it urgently needs to be changed. There is no recourse once it is nullified.

 

The Economic Impact of Justice Delayed Becomes Growth Denied

 If justice is delayed, growth will be rejected. The nation is affected by civil justice delays, both in terms of litigants and the economy. Bangladesh has a lot to offer in terms of potential profitability, but foreign and local investors are hesitant to invest there because of the judiciary's tendency to be untrustworthy, tardy, and lethargic. According to a study by NSU, "long-running legal disputes erode Economic Development and deteriorate the business environment; additionally, the effects are weakest in the property rights and the contract enforcements," stated Mong Khan, a member of the CDC executive council. Bangladesh scores poorly on international indices like the Ease of Doing Business Index due to the inefficiency of contract enforcement. Therefore, court delays affect the economy in addition to the law.


Legal Knowledge and Public Involvement

Increasing Credibility People think that the courts are too costly, too slow, and corrupt. Douglaston Civic Association members gathered in Zion Church Parish Hall were informed by Nassau County Surrogate's Judge Edward W. McCarty III. Thus, informal village arbitration has emerged as the favored choice for the rural populace, despite the fact that it may be quicker but isn't always equitable or rights-based. Restoring public trust requires legal literacy campaigns, rights education in schools, and the presence of local legal aid desks. Organizations like BRAC have been at the forefront of addressing legal literacy models that the villagers, particularly women, can comprehend for the purpose of defending their own rights. It is necessary for these programs to be implemented on a national level.


Conclusion

Lastly, here are some further ideas: To a complete overhaul, it should have taken a Nirmala to be lost, demonstrating the extent of the silent crisis that has gripped Bangladesh's civil justice system. These reforms cover a variety of topics, including the financial costs of court delays, community outreach and victim participation, victim support, prison reform, digitalization, and women and minorities. Deferred justice erodes trust, prevents a reversal or degradation of rights, and blocks justice. If the civil justice system in Bangladesh is to advance, it must change from being a cumbersome, paper-based organization to one that is more transparent and easily accessible.


1 Comments

Previous Post Next Post